FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
A rabbinical advocate (“toen rabani”) is a person authorized to represent people in cases before rabbinical courts, similar to a lawyer in general litigation. Some specialize in family law — divorce, ketubah, alimony, and inheritance — while others specialize in monetary matters, asset disputes, and drafting agreements, among other areas.
A rabbinical advocate who represents clients in the state rabbinical courts for family-law matters must pass examinations and receive certification and a license from the Chief Rabbinate. By contrast, a rabbinical advocate representing clients in monetary matters before private batei din is not required to pass any examinations or hold any license in order to represent parties there. It is important to note, however, that holding a license does not guarantee that a person is truly knowledgeable and expert in the relevant halachic areas. It is therefore advisable to find a genuine expert who can protect your rights reliably and effectively, rather than being drawn in by grandiose promises from those without real experience or training.
There are three types of batei din in Israel: the state’s regional rabbinical courts, which hear divorce, ketubah and other family matters; private batei din, which hear monetary disputes under an arbitration agreement; and a few private batei din that are also authorized to hear family matters and arrange a get.
The first type is the regional state rabbinical courts found in every district, such as the Jerusalem Regional Rabbinical Court. These are operated by the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and are authorized by the state legal system. In the eyes of the law, these batei din are defined as courts, and they have jurisdiction over family law, inheritance, and hekdesh (religious trust) matters. Their authority in these areas runs parallel to that of the general court system, which is likewise authorized to hear these matters — except for divorce and ketubah claims and the actual arranging of a get, which must go through the rabbinical court; the civil court has no authority over these, even if both parties agree to it. As a result, two judicial systems operate in parallel in Israel, and whichever system a case is first filed in generally retains jurisdiction over everything connected to that claim going forward. This creates what is known as the “race to the courthouse,” where each side rushes to file in the forum of their choice, thereby dragging the other side into litigating there as well, against their will.
There is an important distinction within the areas of jurisdiction granted to the rabbinical court: its authority to hear family-law matters does not depend on the parties’ consent, so if someone is sued in the rabbinical court over a divorce-related matter, they are legally required to appear there and have no right to insist on a different forum, such as the civil court. This is not the case for inheritance matters — there, the rabbinical court only has jurisdiction if all the heirs/beneficiaries of the estate accept its authority. Otherwise, one party cannot be forced to litigate before the rabbinical court, unlike the civil court, where a hearing on inheritance matters can be initiated and all beneficiaries are required to participate, even against their will.
At one time, the rabbinical court also had authority to rule on monetary matters, but following the 2006 ruling of Israel’s Supreme Court (HCJ 8638/03, Sima Amir v. the Great Rabbinical Court), it was stripped of jurisdiction over monetary claims, even with the consent of both parties.
The second type of batei din are the so-called private battei din. These are private bodies, generally run by communities or various religious organizations, that provide adjudicative services to those who come before them. These battei din rule according to Jewish law (halacha), as set out in the Shulchan Aruch and its commentaries, while taking civil law into account in certain respects. Their primary authority derives from Torah law, which empowers expert dayanim to adjudicate monetary disputes and to obligate or exempt a party according to the rules established in halacha. Today, before such a beit din begins hearing a case, the parties customarily accept its authority through a kinyan (a formal act, such as lifting an item of value), which obligates them under halacha to comply with the beit din’s rulings. Someone who disregards the beit din is considered to have transgressed and may face social repercussions within the Haredi/religious community. Although the law does not recognize the concept of kinyan in this context, a private beit din’s jurisdiction can still be established in a manner that is legally binding, under the Arbitration Law (1968), which provides that parties to a dispute may appoint an arbitrator to decide the matter between them. The agreed arbitrator may be a single arbitrator or any other number of decision-makers. Under this law, once parties have signed an arbitration agreement for a particular beit din, they are deemed to have accepted its authority to adjudicate between them, and are legally bound to act according to the arbitrator’s ruling they signed onto. If a party fails to comply with the arbitrator’s ruling, they may be held in contempt of court and penalized under the law with fines and the like, just as if they had failed to comply with a court ruling. (To this end, the arbitrator’s ruling must be confirmed by the relevant district court — a simple procedural step that can be done independently or with the help of a lawyer.)
The third type of beit din is the private battei din that also rule on family-law matters. There are a small number of battei din (the Eda Chareidis Beit Din in Jerusalem, and the Bnei Brak Beit Din founded by Rabbi Nissim Karelitz zt”l) that also deal with family law, and which have an arrangement with the Chief Rabbinate permitting them to rule on family-law matters by consent, and even to arrange a get. Their authority in these matters is limited, and it should be verified whether they will hear the specific matter you wish to bring before them.
The “race to the courthouse” is when each spouse rushes to file first, because whoever files first decides whether property, support and custody will be heard in the rabbinical court or in the civil family court.
Israel has a unique legal reality: two parallel court systems — the rabbinical court for family matters and the civil family court — both of which have jurisdiction to hear family-law cases.
The jurisdiction of each is not identical, but very close. For example, arranging a get and ketubah claims can only be handled by the rabbinical court, since actually carrying out a get, as well as anything relating to a ketubah, are inherently religious matters that only authorized religious authorities may handle — as our sages state in Tractate Gittin, that anyone who does not know the intricacies of divorce and marriage documents should have nothing to do with them.
The other claims connected to divorce — such as property claims, spousal support and residence, child support and residence, and child custody — may be brought before either forum, and this is where the “race to the courthouse” begins. Even though these claims can be filed in either forum, once one party has filed in a particular forum, the other party is locked into that forum and cannot transfer the case to the other forum without the consent of the party who filed it, who would need to withdraw it and refile in the parallel forum. This sometimes creates a situation where one party files certain claims before the rabbinical court and other claims relating to the same family dispute before the civil court, which significantly complicates representation and case management.
The race to the courthouse begins the moment one party opens a file with the Dispute Resolution Unit, which is the mandatory first step for anyone wishing to begin divorce proceedings. A file can be opened either with the unit attached to the rabbinical court or with the parallel unit attached to the civil court. After opening a file with the dispute-resolution unit, the parties must wait two months before either one may open a case in the rabbinical court or the civil court — this is meant to give the unit’s staff a full opportunity to help the parties reach an agreement (something that, in practice, usually does not succeed). At the end of those two months, the party who opened the file with the dispute-resolution unit has an additional 15 days during which only they may open cases and sue in whichever forum they see fit. On the 16th day after the waiting period ends, the other party is also permitted to file. During that window, whoever files first wins the “race to the courthouse,” and it is that party who determines whether the couple’s cases will be heard in the rabbinical court or the civil court.
Yes, but it depends on whether the other side agrees. If both sides agree, they submit a joint request to the Beis Din that approved the agreement, and the change is usually approved at a short hearing. Without the other side’s consent, the chances are low: clauses about the children can be changed if it is proven that the arrangement harms them, while the division of assets is reopened only if it is proven that assets or income were presented incorrectly, whether on purpose or by mistake.
Changing the agreement by consent
If both sides agree to a change, they submit a joint request signed by both of them, together with the new version of the agreement or a signed addendum. The Beis Din usually schedules a hearing, to make sure both sides understand what the change means and that the changes are sound both halachically and legally. For very minor changes, the Beis Din may approve the request without a hearing. The hearing is usually scheduled within less than a month, though there are no guarantees.
Changing the agreement without consent
When one side wants to change the agreement and the other refuses, it is possible to ask the Beis Din to change or cancel the agreement, but the chances are usually low. The Beis Din may reject the request outright, based on the reasons given in it, or call both sides to a hearing, which is usually scheduled within three to four months.
This is because an agreement approved by the Beis Din or the court has the force of a ruling, and asking to cancel it is in effect claiming that the court made a mistake when it approved it. Batei din give great weight to the stability of approved agreements, and are careful not to set a precedent that would invite many more such requests.
The best approach is usually to prove that circumstances have changed since the agreement was signed, or that the original circumstances were assessed incorrectly, in a way that makes the agreement unworkable.
Which clauses can be changed?
Not all parts of the agreement are equally open to change.
Clauses about the children, such as parenting time and child support, are easier to change. Parents do not own their children, so the arrangement must be in the children’s best interest, and if it is proven that the current arrangement harms them, that is a good reason to change it.
For parenting time, it is usually enough to prove that the arrangement is not good for the child. Child support is more complicated: if the mother agreed at the time to a low amount, she cannot later claim that it harms the children, since she can support them from other sources, and the low amount really harms her rather than them. Only if she proves that she has no other way to support them, for example from her own income, may the Beis Din see this as a valid reason to change the amount set in the agreement.
The division of assets is almost never reopened. Only if it is proven that, when the agreement was signed, assets or income were presented incorrectly, whether on purpose or by mistake, is there a chance of reopening it. Otherwise, the Beis Din will rule that the sides agreed and cannot change their minds.
Spousal support is usually not relevant after the divorce, since according to halacha, the husband’s duty to support his wife ends once the get is given. It is relevant only in an agreement between spouses who stayed married, and then the answer is almost always that the sides agreed and cannot change their minds.
Claims of pressure or coercion
Cancelling an agreement on the grounds of pressure or coercion is very difficult. If the agreement was made in the Beis Din itself, such a claim will not be accepted. If the agreement was made outside the Beis Din and only approved there, it is possible in theory to bring evidence that one side signed under pressure, but the chances are low: the Beis Din was supposed to check, when approving it, that it was not signed under coercion, and claiming that it was approved anyway is in effect claiming that the Beis Din made a mistake.
If the Beis Din rejects the request, it is possible to appeal to the Rabbinical High Court (Beis Din Hagadol) or to petition the High Court of Justice (Bagatz), which find it easier to criticize the lower court (see below about turning to the High Court of Justice), but there too the chances are low.
Where to file
An agreement approved by the Beis Din stays under the Beis Din’s authority, and the Family Court will not hear it, and the reverse is also true. A request to change an agreement approved by the Beis Din, for example because of a change in circumstances, is filed with the Beis Din that approved it. A claim against the approval itself is filed as an appeal to the Rabbinical High Court.
The High Court of Justice stands above all the courts, but turning to it raises halachic issues, and one should consult a qualified dayan and get his consent before doing so.
Before you file, it’s important to know
- Many people overestimate their chances.
- It’s important to act on time. An appeal that isn’t filed by the deadline, or isn’t followed up properly, becomes a waste of time.
- The Rabbinical High Court often asks the side appealing to deposit the disputed amount, or close to it, to show they are serious. Those who don’t deposit it have their request rejected. It’s worth preparing for this in advance.
- Representation in these proceedings is usually more expensive, because it is a narrow area of expertise and the deadlines are rigid, so the work is done under pressure.
For more information, see: Divorce Agreements. See also on this page: Is a divorce agreement binding without the Beis Din’s approval?
To start a divorce in Israel, you first file a “request to settle the dispute.” Only if no agreement is reached within two months can a claim be filed in the rabbinical court or the family court.
The get itself is given by the Beis Din, but in most cases you cannot file a divorce claim directly. Under the Family Disputes Settlement Law, you must first file a “request to settle the dispute” (bakasha leyishuv sichsuch). Both spouses are then invited to information and coordination meetings at the Assistance Unit (Yechidat Siyua) to see whether they can reach an agreement.
Once the request is filed, proceedings are on hold for two months for both sides: neither spouse may file a claim about the dispute. If no agreement is reached by the end of the two months, the spouse who filed the request gets 15 more days in which only they may file a claim, so only they choose whether it goes to the Beis Din or to the Family Court. After those 15 days, whoever files first chooses where the case is heard.
Because of this, deciding who files the request, and when, can affect the whole process, and it is best decided together with a rabbinical advocate.
There are exceptions: in cases of violence, and for urgent requests such as exit orders or injunctions, you can go to the court or Beis Din right away. A couple filing a divorce agreement together for approval also does not need to go through this stage.
For more information, see: Divorce Filing.
A welfare officer is a social worker appointed by the Minister of Welfare under a specific law, which gives them powers an ordinary social worker does not have.
This is not a profession but a legal role. Those powers include applying to the court, filing official reports, and in some cases acting immediately to protect someone. Each appointment is tied to a particular law, so there are several kinds of welfare officers: under the Youth Law (Care and Supervision), dealing with children at risk, who may remove a child from home in an emergency; under the Legal Capacity and Guardianship Law; under the Adoption of Children Law; and others.
One kind of welfare officer is the court social worker – see the next question.
A court social worker is one kind of welfare officer, whose job is to look into disputes between parents over their children and give recommendations to the Family Court or the Beis Din.
A court social worker (oved sotziali lesidrei din) is appointed under the Welfare (Procedure in Matters of Minors, Mentally Ill Persons and Absent Persons) Law, 1955. Their main job is to assist the Family Court or the Beis Din in disputes between parents over their children: custody, parenting time, relocating with the children, choice of school, and the like. The court or Beis Din instructs them to examine the family and submit a report (taskir) with recommendations, and sometimes also appoints them to supervise visitation, for example at a supervised contact center, or to follow the family over time.
The practical difference: a court social worker is expected to be neutral between the two parents and give the court a professional picture, while a Youth Law welfare officer acts to protect a child at risk, and often stands against the parents themselves.
Worth knowing: decisions and rulings often simply say “the welfare officer”. Usually this means the court social worker, but it is worth checking which law the person was appointed under, since that determines what they are allowed to do. Also, the court’s Assistance Unit (Yechidat Siyua) is a separate body that handles intake meetings and mediation, and is not the welfare officer.
For more information, see: Custody and Guardianship.
No. Under Israeli law, any financial agreement between a married, divorcing or divorced couple that sets out how their financial relationship will work is valid only once it has been approved by either the Family Court or the Regional Rabbinical Court (Beis Din). A prenuptial agreement can also be approved by a notary. Until one of these recognized bodies has reviewed and approved the agreement and given it the status of a psak din (a ruling), it is not binding, even if it was signed in front of witnesses, and either side can withdraw their signature.
To have an agreement approved, the couple sends a request signed by both of them to the court or Beis Din of their choice, along with a copy of the agreement and proof that the filing fee was paid. The Beis Din or court then sets a hearing to review the agreement, usually within about three weeks of filing. At the hearing, the dayanim or judges may change or remove problematic clauses and have both sides sign to show they agree.
Once an agreement has been approved, it is very hard, though not impossible, to cancel it, or even to change it, without the other side’s consent.
Note that terms between parents about the children’s wellbeing, such as custody arrangements, may not be binding even after approval. Children are not their parents’ property, and their wellbeing comes before anything the parents agreed to.
For more information, see: Divorce Agreements.
An appeal must be filed within 30 days of receiving the judgment. In special cases, the Rabbinical High Court (Beit Din Hagadol) may extend the deadline for filing an appeal when extenuating circumstances apply. As an extension is not guaranteed, it’s better to file early and update your appeal later if necessary.
Yes, it is often recommended, and in second marriages it is considered standard practice. Although the law states that assets owned prior to the marriage remain with the original owner, a Supreme Court ruling allows for some assets to be divided equally in the event of a divorce, even if they were owned by only one party before marriage. Therefore, when substantial assets are involved, such as an apartment, a prenuptial agreement is advisable.
You can ask the Beis Din to hear the case again if the new evidence was not known at the time of the original hearing. How you do this depends on the type of Beis Din.
In a private Beis Din, you go back to the same Beis Din, and the case usually returns to the same dayanim who heard it. In Jewish law, unlike civil law, the principle of “finality of proceedings” does not automatically close the case, so it can be reopened at any time if the new evidence was unknown during the original proceedings. However, the Beis Din may ask for a deposit to make sure the request is made in good faith and not just to stall.
In the state regional rabbinical court, there are two options: a request to the same Beis Din to reconsider its ruling (iyun mechadash), or an appeal to the Rabbinical High Court (Beis Din Hagadol). An appeal must be filed within 30 days of receiving the ruling, and here too the Beis Din may ask for a deposit before hearing the appeal.
It’s worth consulting a Toen Rabbani before choosing, since each route has its own rules and deadlines.
Typically, the rabbinical court hears cases before three judges, with the exception of technical rulings or temporary ordinances that do not determine the outcome of the case. These can include asset freezing, travel restriction orders, cease and desist, and restraining orders, where a single judge may preside.
Additionally, if both sides accept the authority of a single Judge, monetary issues can also be decided without a full Beit Din of three Dayanin.
No, unless both sides consent. The rabbinical court and the family court have parallel jurisdiction over spousal support, but once the claim has been opened in one of them, whether the Beis Din or the court, it cannot be moved to the other without the consent of both sides.
With an agreement, usually about three weeks once the agreement is reached. Without one, at least about five months, and usually no less than nine.
Once the couple has reached an agreement, approving it in the Beis Din and arranging the get usually takes about three weeks.
Without an agreement, the process goes through several stages:
Yes, you can file a claim without a Toen Rabani, but it may lead to unwanted and unfortunate outcomes. Because of the emotional involvement, self-representation is often highly stressful, and ineffective. Working with a competent Toen Rabani will save you money and heartache, and will speed up the process, enabling you to get back to rebuilding your life sooner, and from a place of strenght.
A ketubah is a document in which the husband commits, at the wedding, to support his wife and to pay her a sum of money if they divorce.
Our Sages (Talmud Bavli, Ketubot 82b) instituted the ketubah for a wife in order to establish the framework of obligations between spouses — including the husband’s duty to provide for his wife’s sustenance and medical care (and even her burial, God forbid) — but above all, to protect her and make divorce more difficult, so as to prevent unnecessary divorces and help her rebuild her life after a divorce or widowhood. To this end, they set a non-trivial sum: 200 zuz, plus an additional 200 zekukim of pure silver as a tosefet ketubah (supplementary ketubah amount) — a sum that, in today’s currency, comes to over 10,000 NIS (this is according to Ashkenazi custom, which sets a fixed amount; among Sephardim, the sky is the limit, as it is common to add tens or even hundreds of thousands to the base sum). In the event of divorce, the husband is obligated to pay this sum to his wife — giving him real reason to think twice before deciding to divorce her.
There are many additional halachic details regarding the ketubah, not all of which appear in the text of the ketubah document itself — they are found in Tractate Ketubot and in the Shulchan Aruch, but this is the foundation. To this day, it remains a powerful tool for slowing the runaway train toward divorce, since the husband knows he will owe a substantial sum if the marriage ends.
Today, even though Israel’s property relations law already entitles a wife to half of the couple’s joint assets, the ketubah still plays a real role in every divorce case — serving as an important bargaining chip in the wife’s hands: to waive it and let the get (Jewish divorce) proceed, sometimes in exchange for significant concessions from the other side, or to insist on payment and extend the divorce process until her right to the ketubah is resolved.
This is because a wife is not automatically entitled to ketubah payment in every case — there are circumstances in which she may forfeit that right through actions that cause the breakdown of the marriage. The general rule is that the spouse who leaves the home, or whose intolerable behavior causes the other spouse to leave, risks losing in a ketubah claim. In other words, if the beit din rules that the breakdown of the marriage was caused by the husband, he will have to pay the ketubah in full. Conversely, if the wife is found to be at fault, she stands to lose her right to receive ketubah payment.
By Rabbi Nosson Ehrlich, Dayan at the “Nachalei HaMishpat” Beit Din, Jerusalem, and the “Choshen Mishpat” Beit Din, Elad
Arbitration is a judicial process that takes place outside the framework of the official court system. The Arbitration Law allows parties involved in a dispute to appoint a person, or even a panel of people, to decide the disagreement between them. The parties must sign an arbitration agreement that authorizes the agreed-upon arbitrator and sets the terms for how the arbitration will be conducted.
It is also possible to appoint a beis din (rabbinical court) or a single dayan as the agreed-upon arbitrator. In this way, the law grants recognition to the halachic judicial process, since after signing an arbitration agreement and conducting the arbitration proceeding, the arbitrator issues a ruling or written decision that is binding on the parties under civil law as well.
If one of the parties fails to comply with the arbitrator’s ruling, the other party may have the award confirmed by the District Court. Once the ruling has been confirmed by the court, it can be enforced like any court judgment, and a party who refuses to comply with it is subject to fines and further penalties under the Contempt of Court Ordinance.
It should be noted that just as an arbitrator’s ruling can be confirmed by the court, it can likewise be appealed — but as with most appeals that are summarily dismissed, an appeal against an arbitrator’s ruling is usually rejected. This is because civil law and the court system support the institution of arbitration as a way to reduce the courts’ caseload, so they tend to uphold and confirm the vast majority of rulings issued by arbitrators without even engaging with the reasoning behind them.
It should also be noted that an arbitrator’s ruling can be confirmed even after time has passed, but an appeal against an arbitrator’s ruling can only be filed within 45 days of the ruling being issued. This means that in cases where confirming the ruling might prompt the other party to try to have it overturned, one can simply wait 45 days before submitting the ruling for confirmation, by which point the right to appeal has already expired (though it is sometimes possible to be granted leave to appeal even after the 45 days have passed, the chances of that are even lower).
Still have a question?
Talk to us directly, with no obligation.